The Great Crate Debate

In my last post, I wrote to you about CAFOs and swine. One particular hot button topic in the realm of swine operations is the use of gestation crates. These are not to be confused with farrowing crates, which are crates that are used when the sow is giving birth. Farrowing crates keep the piglets safe because mothers have the tendency to roll over on them and kill them without noticing. Farrowing crates allow the piglets to still suckle on the mother without running the risk of getting rolled over. Gestation crates are metal enclosures that hold a pregnant sow through the duration of her pregnancy. She can move forward and backward but she cannot turn around. Those against the use of gestation crates argue that it is inhumane to keep an animal in such a small enclosure and unable to interact socially with other animals. Proponents of gestation crates will tell you that it is easier to monitor the health of the animal, give her the exact amount of food she needs to have a healthy pregnancy, and that they reduce the amount of litters lost. I think the jury is still out on this one. Even as a member of the animal agriculture community, I can see how the general public has a hard time wrapping their heads around this one. But I can also see the benefits to individual attention given by using gestation crates. The best compromise I have found so far are free-access gestation crates. They have little doors on the back that drop down when the pig enters the stall, and if they want to exit the stall and return to the open area, all they have to do is back up and the door will open. The funny thing about these, though, is that even given the free choice to an open area, you're still going to find most of the sows in their crates. Which makes me wonder, what environment do they actually prefer? Are we forcing them into open areas when they would rather be closed in? Or are we closing them in against their will? I don't think the debate about using crates will ever be put to rest. But I can tell you from firsthand experience that, crates or no crates, American pork producers are working every day to create the best product possible with the best animal environment possible.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Antibiotics in my meat?!

Gassy in the Greenhouse

Now, everybody concentrate!